| 1 | Joyful, Joyful, We Adore Thee (Traditional) |
| 2 | O Come All Ye Faithful (Traditional) |
| 3 | Let There Be Peace (Carrie Underwood, Brett James, David Garcia) |
| 4 | Little Drummer Boy (featuring Isaiah Fisher) (Harry Simeone, Henry Onorati, Katherine Davis) |
| 5 | Sweet Baby Jesus (Carrie Underwood, Brett James, David Garcia) |
| 6 | Hallelujah (with John Legend) (John Stephens, Toby Gad) |
| 7 | O Holy Night (Traditional) |
| 8 | Mary, Did You Know? (Buddy Greene, Mark Lowry) |
| 9 | Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas (Ralph Blane, Hugh Martin) |
| 10 | Away In A Manger (Traditional) |
| 11 | Silent Night (Traditional) |
